The Pilgrims shared the first Thanksgiving with the Wampanoag Indians. What caused the relationship between the two groups to fall apart? Check all that are true. The colonists began settling on the tribes' lands that surrounded Plymouth. English colonists stopped trying to work with the tribe and were hostile towards them. The Pilgrims tried to force their religion on the tribe. The governor of the Pilgrims had Squanto killed when he came to the colony to trade goods.​