subject
History, 22.02.2021 20:50 sierraaasifuent

THIS IS THE ANSWER, I GOT A 95% Use the passage below to answer parts A, B, and C of the question that follows.

"Exactly a century ago, on April 24th 1915, Ottoman officials rounded up scores of Armenian intellectuals in Istanbul, most of whom were later murdered. What followed is still bitterly contested. According to the official Turkish version, perhaps 500,000 Armenians died, some while fighting alongside invading Russians against Ottoman forces and others as a regrettable side-effect of deportations that were understandable in the context of the times. But many scholars say that 1m–1.5m Armenians died, and that their deaths were a result of a deliberate campaign to eliminate the Ottoman empire’s only sizeable Christian population. Members of the Armenian diaspora want the events recognised as genocide. What marks genocide out from other mass killings, and why does it matter what word is used?

In 1948 the United Nations adopted a convention aimed at preventing and punishing genocide, which it defined as the ‘deliberate and systematic destruction, in whole or in part, of an ethnical, racial, religious or national group’. Getting agreement on the text involved compromises. Targeting victims because of their class, for example, was not classed as genocide: Stalin would hardly have signed if it meant being held to account for his mass slaughters of ‘middle peasants’ and the like.”

An excerpt from "What Counts as a Genocide,” by H. J., The Economist, April 24, 2015

a) Identify ONE way that the killing of Jewish people during the Holocaust fits the author’s definition of genocide.
b) Explain ONE specific historical example (outside of the author’s example and the example in prompt A) of an act of genocide, based on the author’s definition of genocide.
c) Explain ONE specific historical example of a mass killing that would not meet the author’s definition of genocide.

A) One way that the killing of Jewish people during the Holocaust fits the author’s definition of genocide is that, in the definition that is given, it specifically lists killing something for their religious and ethnic identities. Jewish people can be both a religious and ethnic group, as it is both fundamentally a religion, but coincides a lot with culture and tradition. So, by the author’s definition of genocide, the killing of Jewish people fit the author’s definition of genocide perfectly.

B) One specific historical example of genocide that fits the author’s definition of genocide is the Rwandan genocide. The Rwandan genocide was caused by an imbalance of power in the government between the Hutu and the Tutsi ethnic groups, and a genocide was carried out by the Hutu towards the Tutsi. By the author’s definition of genocide, that Tutsi were specifically targeted for the ethnic background, and were victims of genocide for that reason.

C) One specific historical example of a mass killing that would not meet the author’s definition of genocide is the mass murders that Joseph Stalin carried out while he was in charge of the Soviet Union. He killed many people, and this would be classified a genocide if it were not for the fact that he specifically targeted these people based on what class they were or if they were disloyal to the government. The UN only recognizes a genocide as the government purposefully persecuting people based on their ethnicity, race, religion, or nationality, and it has no mention of class structure or of political views. The only reason that this was the case for the official UN definition is that Stalin, as a member of the UN, would not agree to the definition if he were to be held accountable for his crimes.

ansver
Answers: 2

Another question on History

question
History, 21.06.2019 18:00
Select 3 oral histories from the section entitled, "oral histories of long walk events", and explain how you would feel if this experience happened to you
Answers: 3
question
History, 22.06.2019 02:40
In a court trail, the defendant is the person that a. is arguing the case before the court.b. is accused of a crime. c. is in charge of the jury.d. is defending the person accused of a crime.
Answers: 2
question
History, 22.06.2019 03:30
Why is the end of the cold war tied to the american domestic economy during this time?
Answers: 1
question
History, 22.06.2019 06:30
What primary benefit did theodore roosevelt’s see in digging a canal through panama?
Answers: 1
You know the right answer?
THIS IS THE ANSWER, I GOT A 95% Use the passage below to answer parts A, B, and C of the question t...
Questions
question
Mathematics, 02.07.2021 05:40
question
Mathematics, 02.07.2021 05:50
question
Chemistry, 02.07.2021 05:50
question
Mathematics, 02.07.2021 05:50