Read the following scenario. Then, take a position on this question and write a persuasive essay in which you argue for your position. Be sure to provide reasons for your position and examples to support your reasons. This essay should contain at least TWO paragraphs. Also, include a ONE SENTENCE counterclaim and immediately refute it. The counter claim may begin like this: "Some people may believe that"

And the refute should begin like this: "However" or "I disagree because" or "they are wrong because." You want your refute to be longer with more details than the one sentence counterclaim.

DO NOT begin your response with "yes" or "no." Instead, begin with a topic sentence that includes your position.

Prompt:

Josh has been in a band with his friends since they were little kids. As he has grown older, Josh has come to recognize that he is a better musician than his friends are. Instead of playing in his friends' garage band, Josh is thinking about joining the all-city jazz band, where he can play with and learn from some of the best musicians around.

Should Josh join the jazz band instead of playing with his friends? Consider the positions below as you think about how you would answer this question.