The Preamble of the U.S. Constitutionâthe documentâs famous first fifty-two wordsâ introduces everything that is to follow in the Constitutionâs seven articles and twenty-seven amendments. It proclaims who is adopting this Constitution: âWe the People of the United States.â It describes why it is being adoptedâthe purposes behind the enactment of Americaâs charter of government. And it describes what is being adopted: âthis Constitutionââa single authoritative written text to serve as fundamental law of the land. Written constitutionalism was a distinctively American innovation, and one that the framing generation considered the new nationâs greatest contribution to the science of government. Â
The word âpreamble,â while accurate, does not quite capture the full importance of this provision. âPreambleâ might be takenâwe think wronglyâto imply that these words are merely an opening rhetorical flourish or frill without meaningful effect. To be sure, âpreambleâ usefully conveys the idea that this provision does not itself confer or delineate powers of government or rights of citizens. Those are set forth in the substantive articles and amendments that follow in the main body of the Constitutionâs text. It was well understood at the time of enactment that preambles in legal documents were not themselves substantive provisions and thus should not be read to contradict, expand, or contract the documentâs substantive terms. Â
But that does not mean the Constitutionâs Preamble lacks its own legal force. Quite the contrary, it is the provision of the document that declares the enactment of the provisions that follow. Indeed, the Preamble has sometimes been termed the âEnacting Clauseâ of the Constitution, in that it declares the fact of adoption of the Constitution (once sufficient states had ratified it): âWe the People of the United States . . . do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.â
Importantly, the Preamble declares who is enacting this Constitutionâthe people of âthe United States.â The document is the collective enactment of all U.S. citizens. The Constitution is âownedâ (so to speak) by the people, not by the government or any branch thereof. We the People are the stewards of the U.S. Constitution and remain ultimately responsible for its continued existence and its faithful interpretation. Â
It is sometimes observed that the language âWe the People of the United Statesâ was inserted at the Constitutional Convention by the âCommittee of Style,â which chose those wordsârather than âWe the People of the States of . . .â, followed by a listing of the thirteen states, for a simple practical reason: it was unclear how many states would actually ratify the proposed new constitution. (Article VII declared that the Constitution would come into effect once nine of thirteen states had ratified it; and as it happened two states, North Carolina and Rhode Island, did not ratify until after George Washington had been inaugurated as the first President under the Constitution.) The Committee of Style thus could not safely choose to list all of the states in the Preamble. So they settled on the language of both âWe the People of the United States.â
Nonetheless, the language was consciously chosen. Regardless of its origins in practical considerations or as a matter of âstyle,â the language actually chosen has important substantive consequences. âWe the People of the United Statesâ strongly supports the idea that the Constitution is one for a unified nation, rather than a treaty of separate sovereign states. (This, of course, had been the arrangement under the Articles of Confederation, the document the Constitution was designed to replace.) The idea of nationhood is then confirmed by the first reason recited in the Preamble for adopting the new Constitutionââto form a more perfect Union.â On the eve of the Civil War, President Abraham Lincoln invoked these words in support of the permanence of the Union under the Constitution and the unlawfulness of states attempting to secede from that union. Â
The other purposes for adopting the Constitution, recited by the Preambleâ to âestablish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterityââembody the aspirations that We the People have for our Constitution, and that were expected to flow from the substantive provisions that follow. The stated goal is to create a government that will meet the needs of the people. Â
P.S. This took me a while to type.